What To Get the Witch Who Has Everything?

November 2025

Friends of Change by Meike Hakkaart (Netherlands artist) - Watercolor

Have you started to make your little holiday shopping lists yet?
I just started planning mine!

It is time to start thinking about what our loved ones like. I pride myself on being a gift giver, it's one of my love languages, so today I'll share my tips on choosing just the right gift for any person in your life, as well as a little list of things we currently have in stock that would be perfect for the witch who already has everything she needs, or you're not sure what all she has!

Questions that help germinate the idea:

Is there anything they NEED?
If they need something, get that for them. If you think there's a chance that someone else might gift them something similar, either include the receipt inside the card or give a gift card with the intention spelled out. If the person is young, or in school, or financially precarious, money is always an appreciated and thoughtful gift.

Do they have the physical space or desire for physical objects?
Not everyone wants or has the space for stuff, so be honest with yourself about this one. If they have a very specific set of needs or preferences, choosing something that won't physically take up space until it eventually breaks down is a considerate and ecologically conscious gift.

What is their biggest passion?
This one can be tricky because this is a dead giveaway, therefore everyone likely runs along this vein. The risk you run with indulging in the obvious is being one of many similar, or even identical gifts. The other risk you run with gifting something to someone deep within a niche is not meeting their specialized standards or requirements that you don't even know about.

Are there any consumable or handmade things they might enjoy?
Restaurant gift certificates, gift baskets filled with treats, and fruit or cookie baskets are classics for a reason. The holidays are an expensive time, and it is a kindness to feed others at this time, or to spend energy on something for someone you love. Gathering with our people over a meal is the whole reason for the season, let's be so real about that. An ever popular option for young folks, parents, or anyone needing a little help is gift certificates to the grocery store are a fantastic choice, everyone needs to eat. Other consumable ideas: incense, candles, bath products, art supplies, flowers, & stationery

What experiences would they delight in?
Is your loved one a daredevil who is ever chasing the adrenaline rush? Book them a skydiving trip. Are they a person of leisure, caring more for indulgence and pleasure? Book them a massage. Are they about to embark on a new path in life? Book them a tarot reading. Do they love to learn new things, or work with their hands? Book them a seat in an upcoming workshop or class. There's an experience for everyone out there, and you can provide an unforgettable gift that shows how much you care.

What would they enjoy but never splurge on?
This is the best one, in my experience. I love to treat friends who rarely treat themselves to splurge items. Cashmere sweaters, solid sterling silver jewelry, large crystals, thick books, and fancy tarot decks are some of my favorite things to treat folks to. I take such pleasure in watching someone's excited reaction to what I got them.

Gem's picks for big holiday surprises: